About Us

Team Tuttle covers all of your needs! We have streamlined the process of buying or selling a home to make it easier for you! We have built a team of industry experts to make sure you have access to local home inspectors, contractors, interior designers, service providers, property managers, lending professionals, title and escrow companies, painters, gardeners, plumbers, electricians home warranty companies and more to provide you with the best service possible!

We are dedicated to providing the most up-to-date market data in the area. Our team is made up of three locals who are caring, knowledgeable professionals that work tirelessly to help you with the home buying and selling process. 

In Search of the Perfect Property? Try our easy to use FAST property search

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!


Sandra Tuttle

A local resident of Summerland Key with husband Kip and golden doodles Elliemae and Lola. She’s a full time agent for over 16+ years and has the tools and technology to educate, inform, and assist buyers from out of the area. She is a recipient of the 2018-2019 BHHS Diamond Award – ranking in top 0.5% of agents nationally and Top Producer Lower Keys Office 2012 – Present. She is able to average 30-40 transactions annually by being a skilled negotiator to get you the best price, representing clients as a buyer agent on any property in the Keys, representation on online auction properties, and having the boating knowledge for the best boating and dock recommendations. Experienced with Estates, Residential, Bank Owned, Short Sales, and Commercial properties—Sandy can help you find your ideal property in the Florida Keys.


“I sell the lifestyle I love! Are you ready to get on with the good life?” Contact me today for all of your real estate needs!


Maurizio Nardi

Maurizio is a native of Tuscany, Italy, where he received an education in architecture before moving to NYC in 1998. Maurizio is a resident of the Florida Keys since 2007 and joined Berkshire Hathaway Home Services, keys real estate (Former American Caribbean Real Estate) team in September 2017 after retiring from his career as a Principal dancer with the Martha Graham Dance Company. Maurizio is an awarded artist and an active member of the community as the founder and Artistic Director of local nonprofit Merging Ideas Developing Arts Corp. and Key West Modern Dance summer study program, promoting art education to the Florida Keys.  Maurizio is a founder member of Team Tuttle and works primarily as Sandra’s Buyers Agent. Maurizio strive to provide buyers the knowledge and love he holds for the Florida Keys and its beautifully unique nature.


Taia Pinholster

A Florida Keys resident for over fifteen years and loves the island lifestyle! She’s always active, being outside, playing music, practicing jiu jitsu, boating, diving, camping, walks in the refuge, gardening and spending time with her dog, cat, friends, and family. A highly motivated professional who listens intently, works hard, and will provide the best quality of service to her clients. She is a proud team member of Team Tuttle and tends to client’s needs continuously, day or night. She is determined to share my enthusiasm and local knowledge with you and help you reach your goal of buying or selling a home in the Keys!